Mama Jo Homestyle Pies in Medina

Good pies

2 years I havr gotten pies here. Service is fast. Definitely call ahead and place your for any holiday. Pumpkin, pecan, and French silk is delicious!

Carmel apple Pie was Awesome and the cherry pastry was very flaky and filling. Reading some of the comments I know from speaking with the staff its better to order your pies (usually a week) ahead of time especially before big holidays. If you wait till last minute or day before it can be difficult to get through or place a order. Don't know about staff being RUDE, they were very polite...

Amazing pies!

Costco's pies are way better!!!

Nope!!! Rude! Obnoxious and they have no clue on how to treat customers. I called today and the lady rudely answered the phone and slammed the phone done when I asked one simple question. I just asked if I could place an order and she Rudely responded " no orders.. Slammed down the phone. So I called back and without even saying hello just stated "no orders" and I interrupted her and asked her if she could just listen and let me ask my question and she responded "what" and I asked her my question then she just hung up! No response. Rude.. Just rude!

Best pie and survives

Thank you for all your hard work at thanksgiving. Love your pies and the customer service is fantastic.

Best ever Pies. Gotta have the Buckeye! Have never been disappointed. Every time I have company, have to take a dish to work or a party Mama Jo's is the answer for me and everyone raves! Great stuff try it.... Almost forgot, staff is ALWAYS polite, warm and friendly.

Delicious Pies and kind staff. Mama Jo's is my family's go to bakery for pies and the staff is always very helpful even when your order was made for pickup at another location, if they have it in stock they are more than happy to fulfill it. The pies are always good and have not been disappointed yet.

Good pie selection. Always fresh a d pleasant! Liked their pecan pie!

Never have had a bad pie. Wish it was closer to my house.

Best pie Ever!

There is no better place in Medina County for pies. Amazing service every time I go and it tastes like grandmas’ pies.

We love MJP! It has become a family tradition for us.

Daughter bought the pie as a surprise for us. The crust was dry , heavy and had a slight burnt taste to it. The filling tasted bland and tinny as if it had come out of a can. Sorry the daughter had spent her hard earned money on it.

Great pies reasonable prices

I'm really picky about pies but this place was surprisingly good for a retail establishment. I was impressed. Still not as good as homemade, but dang tasty.

The buckeye pie is out of this world! I can't stop eating it haha had to put it back in the fridge before I ate the entire pie in one sitting perfect if you like chocolate and peanut butter ! Staff was friendly as well!

I don't even like pie. But I love these pies. French silk is delicious. Balanced well. Crust is amazing. Flaky with a bit of salt with the lucious chocolate French silk. They sell in different sizes. Sometimes I crave it so much I'll buy a tiny one for myself! We have also tried pumpkin, bumbleberry, buckeye, coconut cream...I hate coconut but for some reason even that pie was good. Nothing artificial.

Not open when I really needed it.

All the pies are fantastic!! Love the French silk!!

Carmel Apple Pie is Awesome!!! I have not been to the actual location in Medina because they actually cater a handful of them to the Drug Mart in Brunswick for purchase. It is a small selection but it may save you a trip!